Mark and Doug are two Christian economists seeking to combine economics and theology in a fun, thoughtful, and inviting fashion. The name of the blog is a reference to Jesus' admonition to his disciples to be "wise as serpents and innocent as doves" (Matthew 10:16) when going forth into the world. We hope you join the conversation.
Wednesday, January 23, 2008
There Will Be Old Men
Over the past couple of weeks I have seen two very good movies, No Country for Old Men directed by the Coen Brothers (of innumerable terrific movies' fame) and There Will Be Blood directed by Paul Thomas Anderson, whose Magnolia is one of my favorite movies of all time. Yesterday, these two led the pack in nominations for the Academy Awards. Interestingly, the movies have a similar theme, evil. Evil and sin should an important part of our Christian theology, but they are something that a lot of Christians don't like to talk about. I think these two movies would be a good pair for a church fellowship group DVD party. [Warning, No Country deserves every part of its R rating. It is one of the goriest non-"horror" movies I have ever seen. Blood on the other hand is quite the opposite. Although there is violence, it happens mostly off of the camera view. In Britain, Blood, according to imdb , was first rated as the American equivalent of PG-13. In a highly unusual movie, the movie's producers appealed and were awarded the British equivalent of an R rating.]
So how do these movies differ in their treatment of evil. In No Country EVIL appears in capital letters with fangs. It is the evil of serial killers and mass murderers. In There Will be Blood the evil ends up being as massive, but it derives from the long corrosive attack of every man's sinful nature (the main character's last name is the simple Plainview). At least for me, the fear I felt in No Country is the fear you have when you are awake at night and alone and you hear something rattling around upstairs. The fear I felt in Blood is the fear you have when you are awake and alone at night and your hear something rattling around in your soul.
Of course as Christians our deliverance from that fear is the blood of the cross. The blood of Jesus is clearly one of the "bloods" in the movie. Yet P.T. Anderson has never, in anything I have read, claimed to be crafting a Christian religious message, particularly with regards to Magnolia. His message has always been that if that's what people see in his movies, that's fine, but that's not his intent. Nevertheless, there are two clear messages to me in Magnolia: first) the necessity of healing "salvation", which requires divine intervention, and second) a denial of the universality of that healing, which appears to be withheld from at least two people in the Magnolia landscape. In There Will Be Blood the canvas is reversed. The movie's focus is on two people who do not receive grace and salvation. I believe that a good bible verse to go with a study of There Will Be Blood is Mark 3:28-29.
"I tell you the truth, all of the sins and blasphemies of men will be forgiven them. But whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven: he is guilty of an eternal sin."
I also don't understand some reviewers who believe that Anderson provides only a one-dimensional parody of Christianity. First, my father spent his life in oil fields doing what a lot of people in this movie are doing to earn a living, and I don't think the movie suggests a one-dimensional picture that all oil men are evil. I am certain, from my father's stories, that he saw many of the shady things that go on in this movie. Likewise, just because of the complicated and not at all one-dimensional life trajectory of one character, it's a huge mistake to believe that the movie says that all Christians are foolish. In fact, that assertion is factually wrong. Anderson does have his agents of grace in this movie as in Magnolia, and they are quite obviously Christian. It is just that in this movie, unlike in Magnolia, Anderson's concern is with the ultimately reprobate.
So which movie do I think should win the Academy Award? Well it's like being offered two different cars as a gift. One, No Country for Old Men, is like a beautiful new silver BMW. It's stylish. Every part functions perfectly, and the parts fit together in breathtaking harmony. Your other choice, There Will Be Blood, is like a Classic Series 2 Camaro. It's a gawky yellow, its engine is too big, and the parts sometimes clunk together when you slam the door. But it is awesome fun to drive.
Saturday, December 1, 2007
Whatsamatta U
First, Jeremiah 9: 23-24:
23 This is what the LORD says:
"Let not the wise man boast of his wisdom
or the strong man boast of his strength
or the rich man boast of his riches,
24 but let him who boasts boast about this:
that he understands and knows me,
that I am the LORD, who exercises kindness,
justice and righteousness on earth,
for in these I delight,"
declares the LORD.*
2 It is not good to have zeal without knowledge,
nor to be hasty and miss the way.*
Not surprisingly, the Bible gives us a both/and lesson. It is not good to have zeal without knowledge, but it is also improper to boast about knowldge. One can easily imagine what Jesus would say about people who were either boring intellectual snobs or who showed a dangerous lack of knowledge or wisdom.
The inspiration for today's post is a recent Wall Street Journal article on the 50 or so top highschools ranked by who places the most students at the so-called "elite" schools. I find a perhaps unBiblical fascination about reading about people for whom attending a "non-elite" private school or a public university (or, shudder, waving-off of college to become a comedy writer or an auto mechanic) is some kind a personal tragedy. And the article itself was full of many unanswered questions:
What does anyone get, at the margin, out of attending an so-called elite university?
What does it mean that so many of these schools are either: 1) expensive Northeastern private schools; 2) high stakes admission parochial or public magnet schools; 3) public schools in high income areas?
What is the purpose of lists such as these? What good does it do to tell someone in a grindingly poor rural school district that if only they lived in the Washington D.C. suburbs their chances of going to Princeton would be higher?
Do we next see a list of the top 250 middle schools to get into the to 50 high schools to get into the top elite colleges? Where does it end---admission to college prep kindergardens to get into the top 1000 elementary schools to get into the top 250 middle schools to get into the top 50 high schools to get into the top colleges? (Oh wait, that's already happening.)
And, as with so many of these exercises, this may confuse correlation with causality. Just because you play football in the NFL doesn't mean that your last name changes to Manning. Many of these schools undoubtedly have great "success" precisely because of who they have as students.
There's almost an endless discussion about education reform that could follow on this topic, but I'd like to turn back to the opening bible verses. Sometimes the economist's skill at defining institutions must yield to the Christian's imperative to change people. For students and parents involved in the college admission process, I think it is imperative to ask "Where is God in all of this?" If you believe that your calling is as an actor and going to Yale for drama is the logical and best path, so be it. But the Christian life should not be about credential elitism, snobbery, career anxiety, or making meritocracy one's personal God.
I also think there's something to be said to people such as myself in America's universities. It is not clear whether we are captives or instigators (I believe largely captives), but universities are now and have been for some years caught in a destructive obsession with the rankings sytems that drive student admissions. We all know that this stuff is phony and nonsense, but we are caught in a prisoner's dilemma where no one university can afford to say, like Eric Cartman, "**** you guys, I'm going home."
The quote from Jeremiah suggests that an end to boasting about knowledge would mean not only more justice but also more kindness. I don't know if that's a correct match for the verse to this problem, but it seems to me that we have a system that is neither just, nor righteous, nor kind.
* NIV from Bible Gateway.
Wednesday, November 21, 2007
Morality and Markets
You've probably heard the story of individuals loading up their own single pick-up trucks with plywood and driving to areas affected by a hurricane. Such folks essentially open up shop on their tailgates, charging prices well above what they paid in their (inland) hometowns. I am confident that many Christian clergy find this practice un-Christian and support emergency measures to prevent "price gouging." As an economist and a Christian, I am happy to take the opposite opinion. As an economist, I can explain the objective consequences of price controls (fewer supplies will flow in; more rationing will be by line-standing and illegal markets) as well as the welfare and distributional consequences. As a Christian I have no problem finding these laws wanting (at the end of the day, they just as plausibly hurt as help the poor). [In a longer discussion, I would probably look at some of the moral attributes of different types of pricing or negotiating]. I believe that many if not most economists would agree with my analysis.
But let's expand the example a little. Suppose you have a Christian (even an economist) who loads up his or her pickup-truck and heads to the hurricane zone, but with the express purpose of driving to poorer neighborhoods and either giving away the plywood or selling it for the "inland" pre-hurricane price. From an economist's point of view, has this person been unwise or even unhelpful? I came away from one session believing that there are more economists than I realized who would answer "Yes" to that question, and I have problems with that. Their argument evaluates the specific outcomes themselves.... my hypothetical agent of grace distributed the plywood at other than the market clearing price. I can simultaneously oppose price controls and believe that it is not only acceptable but even praiseworthy to engage in the charitable actions I describe, because to me the essence of the free market is the realization of human freedom, including the freedom of an individual to give away plywood to poor people. But this is only a shadow of a full debate...there is a longer post here and I hope to get back to this in the near future.
Thursday, November 15, 2007
Leviathan
Economists Hungerman and Gruber have a new article forthcoming estimating how much the New Deal “crowded out” similar spending on compassionate activities by American churches. This is consistent with an overall interest by economists and political scientists on why there was such an unprecedented ramp-up in the size of the federal government between World War I and World War II. The wars and the Great Depression are obvious proximate causes, but are we forgetting the role of Christians?
The period between The Civil War and World War I was that of what is sometimes called the “Third Great Awakening”. One of the economic manifestations of this great revival was the so-called “Social Gospel” which had enormous influence on the government-activist populist, progressive, and socialist political movements of the time. (The American Economic Association was a product of the Social Gospel movement). These movements had some direct influences during the so-called progressive era, but more importantly, when the New Deal required intellectual support for federal attempts to end the Great Depression, the Social Gospel – inspired movements had numerous big-government ideas already on the shelf (Social Security, being one example).
Now, Mark Noll of Notre Dame, in a new article in First Things , moves the action back several generations to the Second Great Awakening of the first part of the 19th century. Paradoxically, the effect of this great religious revival was the decentralization and democratization of the institutions of American Christianity. However, the paramount social issue of the Second Great Awakening, abolition, led to the Civil War and the reconstruction Constitutional amendments -- all of which solidified and made unambiguous the notion of a strong, centralized federal government. Noll calls this the Second Founding Era. It is no surprise then that the next generation of Christians in the Social Gospel movement were so much more likely to turn to governments, including the federal government, for solutions.
Doug and I are working on a research project which asks the question: is reverse crowding out possible? Is the transition of compassionate activities to the government a reversible process, or is it simply the nature of the situation that government becomes “locked in” as the solution?
Saturday, November 10, 2007
A Bagel With Your Laute ?
- Praepropere - eating too soon
- Laute - eating too expensively
- Nimis - eating too much
- Ardenter - eating too eagerly
- Studiose - eating too daintily
You don’t have to be a scholastic philosopher to agree that this makes sense. I feel almost queasy when I got to an expensive restaurant and find that I’m paying enormous amounts of money for less food than is in a $4.99 frozen dinner, just so the meat and veggies can be arranged in a design matching, for example, a map of Napoleon’s retreat from Russia. That doesn’t fit the narrow definition of eating too much, but I would agree with Thomas that there something just not right there.
Sunday, November 4, 2007
Oscar Elias Biscet
Jeff Jacoby writes in today’s Boston Globe about the horrific fate of Cuban Christian dissident Oscar Elias Biscet. President Bush will honor Dr. Biscet with the Presidential Medal of Freedom tomorrow. Unfortunately, given that Dr. Biscet is a prisoner in one of Castro’s squalid prisons for “disrespecting patriotic symbols” and speaking out against the regime, he will be unable to receive the prize in person. I had heard about Dr. Biscet, but I had not realized that his initial confrontation with the Castro regime was over the Cuban government’s abortion policy.
Is there anything that we can do? We should keep these brave, faithful believers in our prayers, and continue to make their plight part of our public conversation. Also, please read the Jacoby article [warning, it is explicit about the violence], and share a copy with anyone you know who wears a trendy “Che” t-shirt.
Saturday, November 3, 2007
Mean Streets
Both the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times had articles on the same topic last week: the state of the
These kinds of issues are perpetual paradoxes for Christians concerned about compassion for the poor. The LA program drew on other successful “broken window” programs in which the city prosecutes even low level crimes in a concerted effort to clean up an area. This makes sense from the economic point of view in that social systems can have undesirable equilibria that can not be knocked loose by small changes. In this case, the policy at issue was apparently the crime of pitching tents in the public rights of way on the sidewalk. If a program such as this seems heavy-handed but results in a decrease in crime (and here I mean specifically violent crime inflicted upon the homeless), is it compassionate or not? If, from a Biblical perspective, one could make arguments for or against, is it appropriate for Christians to support using the court system to intervene against the political process?